Roofr's guide runs about 2,200 words with no visible date. It covers Local Services Ads, search ads, Facebook, Nextdoor, Business Profile, referrals, yard signs, door knocking, example budgets for $500K and $1M companies, and tracking with CallRail, UTM tags and a CRM. It gives about 18 figures, none with a source. It leaves out cost per signed job, legal and compliance (review rules, door-to-door, deductibles), Business Profile suspension risks and LSA document requirements. Roofr sells an instant-estimator product and the page promotes it.
MBCI, a metal-panel supplier (Apr 23, 2025), covers brand, websites, SEO, email, social and traditional media, with uncited statistics such as '10,000 brand messages daily.' It does not cover budget, costs, LSA, reviews or attribution. AccuLynx (undated) lists 92 ideas with a few cited statistics, and skips budget percentages, costs, LSA, review compliance and legal. Nextdoor's guide (Apr 23, 2025) covers website, Business Profile, social, Nextdoor ads and referrals, with no statistics or prices and no mention of LSA. Thrive's list is an agency ranking that places its publisher first (97/100), discloses no pricing and says no agency paid for placement.
Across these pages, almost none gives a sourced cost per signed job. None explains LSA verification or Google's review policies in detail, and none addresses Google's doorway and scaled-content policies, even though the results are full of idea lists and agency listicles. Several are undated or old. The homeowner-survey data from Roofing Contractor and BrightLocal goes unused. Those gaps are where a roofer reading carefully can get ahead: verified profile details, a review routine that stays inside the rules, and cost tracked to the signed contract.